HSE HUBby NeuraSafe

HSE HUB › Question of the Day archive › 18 November 2026

CSP practice question: Mitigation: benefit-cost analysis of flood protection

Question of the Day for Wednesday, 18 November 2026

CSP · Emergency Management
A plant's main switchgear sits where there is a 2 percent annual chance of flooding, and a flood would cause about $2.5 million in damage and lost production. Raising the switchgear costs $450,000 and would prevent that loss for 30 years; the present value factor for 30 years at 7 percent is 12.41. What does a benefit-cost analysis show?

Explanation

Mitigation benefits are the expected annual losses avoided, annual probability times consequence: 0.02 x $2.5 million = $50,000 a year. Over the 30-year life at 7 percent that is $50,000 x 12.41 = about $620,000 in present value, so the ratio is 620,000 / 450,000 = about 1.38, and the project is cost-effective. Using the full flood loss treats the flood as certain, summing 30 years without discounting overstates the benefit, and comparing one year's benefit with the whole cost ignores the project's life. Source: FEMA Benefit-Cost Analysis guidance (expected annual damages avoided and present value of benefits).

Practise more questions like this

Studying for the CSP? The CSP11 blueprint explained · How to get the CSP · CSP practice exam by domain · All guides

Unofficial study aid: not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Board of Certified Safety Professionals (BCSP). ASP and CSP are trademarks of BCSP. Questions are original study items written for HSE HUB.