HSE HUB › Question of the Day archive › 28 October 2026
CSP practice question: HAZOP: crediting a safeguard against its design basis
Question of the Day for Wednesday, 28 October 2026
CSP · Program Management
In a HAZOP of a hydrocarbon separator, the team records the deviation 'more pressure', caused by the downstream control valve failing closed while the inlet stays open. The only safeguard listed is relief valve PSV-12. The process safety information shows PSV-12 was sized for the external fire case, and no one has checked its capacity against full inlet flow. How should the team treat PSV-12 for this cause?
Explanation
A safeguard counts in a HAZOP only if it is effective for the specific cause; a relief valve sized for a fire case may not pass the much larger load of a blocked outlet with full inlet flow, so the team should record a recommendation to verify the sizing rather than credit it. PSM requires process safety information that includes relief system design and design basis, and a PHA that addresses the engineering controls applicable to the hazards. Independence and a passed bench test are necessary but do not prove capacity, and an alarm does not make up for an undersized relief path. Source: 29 CFR 1910.119(d)(3)(i)(D) and (e)(3)(iii).Practise more questions like this
Studying for the CSP? The CSP11 blueprint explained · How to get the CSP · CSP practice exam by domain · All guides
Unofficial study aid: not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Board of Certified Safety Professionals (BCSP). ASP and CSP are trademarks of BCSP. Questions are original study items written for HSE HUB.