HSE HUBby NeuraSafe

HSE HUB › Question of the Day archive › 6 September 2026

CSP practice question: Risk analysis: crediting manual isolation in a QRA

Question of the Day for Sunday, 6 September 2026

CSP · Risk Management Answer in HSE HUB Pro
A QRA for a new chlorine unloading station beside an occupied warehouse credits manual isolation for a hose rupture: the unloading operator walks to a shutoff valve 30 feet from the hose and closes it within 2 minutes. The model gives this action a failure probability of 0.01, the same value it uses for the automatic SIL 2 shutdown on the other unloading line, and with that credit the risk to the warehouse sits just inside the company criterion. What is the BEST conclusion for the reviewer?
AAccept the credit, since 0.01 is a normal error rate for a trained operator doing a simple, rehearsed valve closure
BRemove or justify the credit, since the operator may be absent or a casualty and must not enter the cloud without PPE
CImprove the credit to 0.001, since the operator is nearer the hose than any detector and so will react to it sooner
DAccept the credit if the valve is stroke tested yearly, since valve reliability, not the operator, sets its failure rate

See the answer and the full explanation

Answers to Questions of the Day stay open for 30 days. This one, and every question in the bank, is answered and explained in HSE HUB Pro: unlimited practice by domain, the full 200-question mock exam and animated lessons.

See HSE HUB ProTry today's question, answer included

Studying for the CSP? The CSP11 blueprint explained · How to get the CSP · CSP practice exam by domain · All guides

Unofficial study aid: not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Board of Certified Safety Professionals (BCSP). ASP and CSP are trademarks of BCSP. Questions are original study items written for HSE HUB.